10 Hardest ESAT Questions by Thriving Scholars, with a geometric series question visible in an ESAT-style test screen

The hardest questions often start with familiar ideas. The challenge is spotting which ones to connect—and which tempting shortcut will fail.

These ten original problems build on ideas from published ENGAA and NSAA papers, adding a further reasoning step while staying within the ESAT specification. Choose your subjects, try each question, then check the reasoning underneath.

10 original questions · 5 modules · No calculator. Two questions per module. This is a stretch set, not a full mock or a prediction of your score. The questions are newly written; they are not official ESAT questions or recalled test content.

How to use this ESAT challenge

Choose the modules you are preparing for. Work through each problem without a calculator, select an answer and check it. Open the worked solution whenever you are ready; each one includes the key idea, a common trap and its past-paper starting point.

For a broader revision plan, see our ESAT preparation guide. Use the free TMUA and ESAT maths practice bank to mix these stretch problems with regular past-paper practice.

Try the 10 hardest ESAT practice questions

Showing all 10 questions.

Question 1Mathematics 1Geometry & quadratics

One area, two possible lengths

A square ABCDABCD has side length 4 cm4\text{ cm}. Point PP lies on ABAB, point QQ lies on BCBC, and RR is the midpoint of CDCD.

Given that AP=BQ=x cmAP=BQ=x\text{ cm}, with 0<x<40<x<4, the area of triangle PQRPQR is 154 cm2\frac{15}{4}\text{ cm}^2.

What is the positive difference between the two possible values of xx?

Square ABCD with triangle PQR insideA is bottom left, B bottom right, C top right, D top left. P lies on AB, Q on BC and R is the midpoint of CD. AP and BQ both have length x. The square has side 4 centimetres. Diagram not to scale.ABCDPQRxx4 cm
Diagram not to scale. The shaded region is triangle PQR.
Choose one answer for question 1
Show solutionHide solution for question 1

Answer B · 2\sqrt2

Key idea Find the triangle by subtracting the surrounding regions from the square.

  1. The three regions outside PQRPQR are trapezium APRDAPRD, triangle PBQPBQ, and triangle QCRQCR. Their areas are

    2(x+2),x(4−x)2,4−x.2(x+2),\qquad \frac{x(4-x)}2,\qquad 4-x.
  2. Subtract these from the square’s area:

    Area(PQR)=8−3x+x22.\text{Area}(PQR)=8-3x+\frac{x^2}{2}.

    Set this equal to the given area:

    2x2−12x+17=0.2x^2-12x+17=0.
  3. The quadratic formula gives

    x=3±22.x=3\pm\frac{\sqrt2}{2}.

    Both values lie between 0 and 4. Their positive difference is 2\boxed{\sqrt2}.

Common trap Discarding the second root without checking whether it also gives a valid position inside the square.

Conceptual starting point: ENGAA 2023, Section 1, Q5. ESAT scope: M4.16; M5.14.

Question 2Mathematics 1Conditional probability

What did the transfer contain?

Bag X contains 2 red counters and 3 blue counters. Bag Y contains 1 red counter and 2 blue counters. Apart from colour, all counters are identical.

Two counters are selected at random from X, without replacement, and transferred to Y. Two counters are then selected at random from Y, without replacement.

The two counters selected from Y are the same colour.

Given this information, what is the probability that both counters transferred from X were red?

Choose one answer for question 2
Show solutionHide solution for question 2

Answer C · 223\frac2{23}

Key idea Weight each possible transfer by how likely it is to produce the observed result.

  1. Let KK be the number of red counters transferred. There are ten equally likely unordered pairs in X. One pair is red–red, six are mixed, and three are blue–blue.

    Possible transfers and their consequences
    KKTransfer probabilityY after transferProbability of a same-colour pair from Y
    03/103/101 red, 4 blue6/106/10
    16/106/102 red, 3 blue4/104/10
    21/101/103 red, 2 blue4/104/10
  2. So the probability of the observed same-colour pair is

    310610+610410+110410=46100.\frac3{10}\frac6{10}+\frac6{10}\frac4{10}+\frac1{10}\frac4{10}=\frac{46}{100}.
  3. The probability of transferring two reds and then observing a same-colour pair is 4/1004/100. Restricting to the observed outcomes gives

    4/10046/100=223.\frac{4/100}{46/100}=\boxed{\frac2{23}}.

Common trap Using the original 1/10 probability after being given information about the second draw.

Conceptual starting point: NSAA 2023, Section 1, Q20. ESAT scope: M7.5–M7.7.

Question 3Mathematics 2Geometric series

A series hidden inside a series

An infinite geometric series has real first term aa and common ratio rr, where ∣r∣<1|r|<1.

The sum of all its terms is 12. The sum of the terms in the even-numbered positions is −4-4; that is,

ar+ar3+ar5+⋯=−4.ar+ar^3+ar^5+\cdots=-4.

What is the sum of the squares of all the terms of the original series?

Choose one answer for question 3
Show solutionHide solution for question 3

Answer D · 240240

Key idea The even-position terms form a geometric series with ratio r².

  1. The two given sums are

    a1−r=12,ar1−r2=−4.\frac{a}{1-r}=12,\qquad \frac{ar}{1-r^2}=-4.

    Divide the second equation by the first:

    r1+r=−13.\frac{r}{1+r}=-\frac13.
  2. Hence 3r=−1−r3r=-1-r, so r=−14r=-\frac14 and

    a=12(1−r)=15.a=12(1-r)=15.
  3. The squared terms have first term a2a^2 and ratio r2r^2:

    a21−r2=2251−1/16=240.\frac{a^2}{1-r^2}=\frac{225}{1-1/16}=\boxed{240}.

Common trap Squaring the total sum. The square of a sum includes cross-products; it is not the sum of the squares.

Conceptual starting point: ENGAA 2023, Section 1, Q25. ESAT scope: MM2.3.

Question 4Mathematics 2Tangents, factors & integration

Find the contact point before the area

The curve CC has equation

y=x3−3x2+2x.y=x^3-3x^2+2x.

The tangent to CC at the point with xx-coordinate aa, where a>1a>1, meets the curve again at a different point with xx-coordinate bb.

The positive difference between aa and bb is 3.

What is the area of the finite region bounded by the tangent and the curve?

Choose one answer for question 4
Show solutionHide solution for question 4

Answer E · 274\frac{27}{4}

Key idea Subtract the tangent from the cubic, then use its factorisation to locate the second intersection.

  1. Write f(x)=x3−3x2+2xf(x)=x^3-3x^2+2x. Since f′(a)=3a2−6a+2f'(a)=3a^2-6a+2, the tangent is

    y=(3a2−6a+2)x−2a3+3a2.y=(3a^2-6a+2)x-2a^3+3a^2.
  2. Subtracting this line from the curve and factorising gives

    f(x)−ytangent=(x−a)2(x+2a−3).f(x)-y_{\rm tangent}=(x-a)^2(x+2a-3).

    The second intersection is therefore b=3−2ab=3-2a. As a>1a>1, we have a>ba>b, so

    a−b=3a−3=3.a-b=3a-3=3.

    Thus a=2a=2, b=−1b=-1, and the tangent is y=2x−4y=2x-4.

  3. Between these intersections, the curve lies above the tangent because

    f(x)−(2x−4)=(x−2)2(x+1)≥0.f(x)-(2x-4)=(x-2)^2(x+1)\geq0.
  4. The required area is

    ∫−12(x3−3x2+4) dx\int_{-1}^{2}(x^3-3x^2+4)\,\mathrm dx
    =[x44−x3+4x]−12=274.=\left[\frac{x^4}{4}-x^3+4x\right]_{-1}^{2}=\boxed{\frac{27}{4}}.

Common trap Integrating the cubic alone instead of the difference between the curve and the tangent.

Conceptual starting point: ENGAA 2023, Section 1, Q31 and Q33. ESAT scope: MM1.6; MM6.2–MM6.3; MM7.1–MM7.2.

Question 5PhysicsCircuits & electrical power

The switched resistor network

An ideal battery with constant voltage is connected to the resistor network shown. Resistor A has resistance RR, B has resistance 2R2R, and C and D each have resistance RR.

A is in series with two parallel branches: B alone, and C followed by D. Switch S is connected across D only. Wires and the closed switch have negligible resistance.

With S open, the power dissipated in A is 25 W25\text{ W}. The switch is then closed.

What is the new power dissipated in B?

Resistor network with switch S across DAn ideal battery supplies resistor A, resistance R, in series with two parallel branches. The upper branch contains B, resistance 2R. The lower branch contains C then D, each resistance R. An open switch S is wired across D only.A: RB: 2RC: RD: RSV+−
S is shown open. Closing it bypasses D only.
Choose one answer for question 5
Show solutionHide solution for question 5

Answer B · 8 W8\text{ W}

Key idea The battery voltage stays fixed; the voltage across the parallel branches does not.

  1. Let the battery voltage be VV. With S open, the parallel branches each have resistance 2R2R. Their combined resistance is RR, giving total resistance 2R2R.

    Therefore A has voltage V/2V/2, so

    PA,open=V24R=25.P_{A,\rm open}=\frac{V^2}{4R}=25.

    Hence V2/R=100 WV^2/R=100\text{ W}.

  2. Closing S bypasses D. The parallel branches are now 2R2R and RR, with combined resistance 2R/32R/3. The total resistance is 5R/35R/3.

    The voltage across B is the voltage across this parallel combination:

    VB=V2R/35R/3=2V5.V_B=V\frac{2R/3}{5R/3}=\frac{2V}{5}.
  3. Using P=V2/RP=V^2/R for resistor B gives

    PB=(2V/5)22R=225V2R=8 W.P_B=\frac{(2V/5)^2}{2R}=\frac{2}{25}\frac{V^2}{R}=\boxed{8\text{ W}}.

You can obtain a parallel resistance from the current rules: at voltage UU, branches RR and 2R2R draw total current U/R+U/(2R)U/R+U/(2R), equivalent to resistance 2R/32R/3.

Common trap Applying the rise in total circuit current to B. The current through A and the current through B are different.

Conceptual starting point: ENGAA 2023, Section 1, Q4 and Q28. ESAT scope: P1.2f, i–m.

Question 6PhysicsMomentum, energy & springs

A collision before the springs

A 1.0 kg1.0\text{ kg} cart moves at 6.0 m s−16.0\text{ m s}^{-1} and collides with a stationary 3.0 kg3.0\text{ kg} cart. They stick together.

After the collision, the joined carts compress two massless ideal springs connected end-to-end against a fixed wall. The spring constants are 300 N m−1300\text{ N m}^{-1} and 900 N m−1900\text{ N m}^{-1}.

Both springs are initially uncompressed and remain within their linear elastic ranges. Motion is along one horizontal line. Friction and all energy losses after the collision are negligible.

What is the maximum compression of the 300 N m−1300\text{ N m}^{-1} spring?

Choose one answer for question 6
Show solutionHide solution for question 6

Answer C · 0.15 m0.15\text{ m}

Key idea Conserve momentum during the collision, then conserve energy during compression.

  1. Momentum conservation gives the speed just after the collision:

    1(6)=(1+3)v,v=1.5 m s−1.1(6)=(1+3)v,\qquad v=1.5\text{ m s}^{-1}.

    The kinetic energy available to compress the springs is

    12(4)(1.5)2=4.5 J.\frac12(4)(1.5)^2=4.5\text{ J}.
  2. Let the softer spring’s compression be xx. The force is the same through both massless springs, so the stiffer spring compresses by x/3x/3.

  3. At maximum compression, all the joined carts’ kinetic energy is stored in the springs:

    12(300)x2+12(900)(x3)2=4.5.\frac12(300)x^2+\frac12(900)\left(\frac{x}{3}\right)^2=4.5.
    200x2=4.5,x2=0.0225.200x^2=4.5,\qquad x^2=0.0225.

    Taking the positive root gives x=0.15 m\boxed{x=0.15\text{ m}}.

Common trap Conserving kinetic energy through the sticking collision, or reporting the total compression of both springs.

Conceptual starting point: ENGAA 2023, Section 1, Q40. ESAT scope: P3.3c–d; P3.6a–b; P3.7d, f.

Question 7ChemistryMoles, gas volumes & titration

Find the material that did not react

A 2.50 g2.50\text{ g} solid mixture contains sodium carbonate, Na2CO3\mathrm{Na_2CO_3}, sodium hydrogencarbonate, NaHCO3\mathrm{NaHCO_3}, and an inert impurity that does not react with acid.

The mixture reacts completely with 40.0 cm340.0\text{ cm}^3 of 1.00 mol dm−31.00\text{ mol dm}^{-3} hydrochloric acid. All the carbon dioxide produced is collected: its dry volume is 480 cm3480\text{ cm}^3 at room temperature and pressure.

The acid remaining afterwards requires exactly 20.0 cm320.0\text{ cm}^3 of 0.500 mol dm−30.500\text{ mol dm}^{-3} sodium hydroxide for complete neutralisation.

Use a molar gas volume of 24.0 dm324.0\text{ dm}^3, and molar masses of 106 g mol−1106\text{ g mol}^{-1} for Na2CO3\mathrm{Na_2CO_3} and 84 g mol−184\text{ g mol}^{-1} for NaHCO3\mathrm{NaHCO_3}.

What percentage of the original mixture’s mass is inert impurity?

Choose one answer for question 7
Show solutionHide solution for question 7

Answer F · 24%24\%

Key idea The gas measures the total moles of the two salts; the acid measures a differently weighted total.

  1. Initial HCl is 0.0400 mol0.0400\text{ mol}. The remaining HCl is 0.0200×0.500=0.0100 mol0.0200\times0.500=0.0100\text{ mol}, because HCl and NaOH react 1:1.

    So the salts consumed 0.0300 mol0.0300\text{ mol} of HCl.

  2. Let xx and yy be the moles of carbonate and hydrogencarbonate respectively. Each gives one mole of carbon dioxide per mole of salt. Therefore

    x+y=0.48024.0=0.0200.x+y=\frac{0.480}{24.0}=0.0200.

    Carbonate consumes two moles of HCl per mole, while hydrogencarbonate consumes one:

    2x+y=0.0300.2x+y=0.0300.
  3. Subtracting gives x=0.0100x=0.0100, hence y=0.0100y=0.0100. The mass of the two salts is

    (0.0100)(106)+(0.0100)(84)=1.90 g.(0.0100)(106)+(0.0100)(84)=1.90\text{ g}.
  4. The impurity has mass 2.50−1.90=0.60 g2.50-1.90=0.60\text{ g}. Its percentage is

    0.602.50×100=24%.\frac{0.60}{2.50}\times100=\boxed{24\%}.

Common trap Treating all the acid added as acid consumed, or assigning the same acid-to-salt ratio to both salts.

Conceptual starting point: NSAA 2023, Section 1, Q51 and Q54. ESAT scope: C4.3, C4.6, C4.8–C4.10; C9.1b, f.

Question 8ChemistryIncomplete combustion & formulae

Oxygen comes from two places

A saturated alcohol has molecular formula CnH2n+2O\mathrm{C}_n\mathrm{H}_{2n+2}\mathrm O, where nn is a positive integer.

A 3.00 g3.00\text{ g} sample is completely used up in an incomplete-combustion reaction, consuming 4.20 dm34.20\text{ dm}^3 of oxygen at room temperature and pressure.

The only products are carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide and water. The mole ratio CO2:CO\mathrm{CO_2:CO} is 1:21:2.

Use Ar(C)=12A_r(\mathrm C)=12, Ar(H)=1A_r(\mathrm H)=1, Ar(O)=16A_r(\mathrm O)=16, and a molar gas volume of 24.0 dm324.0\text{ dm}^3.

What is the alcohol’s molecular formula?

Choose one answer for question 8
Show solutionHide solution for question 8

Answer B · C3H8O\mathrm{C_3H_8O}

Key idea Count all oxygen atoms in the products, then subtract the oxygen already present in the alcohol.

  1. For one mole of alcohol, the carbon products are n/3n/3 moles of CO2\mathrm{CO_2} and 2n/32n/3 moles of CO\mathrm{CO}. The hydrogen produces n+1n+1 moles of water.

  2. The products therefore contain this many moles of oxygen atoms:

    2(n3)+2n3+(n+1)=7n3+1.2\left(\frac n3\right)+\frac{2n}3+(n+1)=\frac{7n}{3}+1.

    One mole of oxygen atoms comes from the alcohol itself. The oxygen gas required per mole of alcohol is consequently

    12(7n3+1−1)=7n6.\frac12\left(\frac{7n}{3}+1-1\right)=\frac{7n}{6}.
  3. The alcohol’s molar mass is 14n+18 g mol−114n+18\text{ g mol}^{-1}. Use the measured oxygen consumption:

    314n+18×7n6=4.2024.0=740.\frac{3}{14n+18}\times\frac{7n}{6}=\frac{4.20}{24.0}=\frac7{40}.

    This simplifies to 20n=14n+1820n=14n+18, giving n=3n=3.

    The molecular formula is C3H8O\boxed{\mathrm{C_3H_8O}}.

Common trap Counting every oxygen atom in the products as an atom supplied by oxygen gas.

Conceptual starting point: NSAA 2023, Section 1, Q60. ESAT scope: C3.4; C4.1, C4.3, C4.6, C4.8; C13.1f; C13.5a.

Question 9BiologyInheritance & conditional probability

What do two purple offspring tell you?

In a plant species, purple flowers are determined by a dominant allele AA; white flowers occur only in plants with genotype aaaa.

Two heterozygous plants are crossed. One purple-flowered offspring is selected at random and self-pollinated.

The first two offspring of this selected plant both have purple flowers.

Assume ordinary Mendelian inheritance, no mutations or differences in survival, and independent fertilisations for a fixed parental genotype.

Given all this information, what is the probability that the selected plant’s next offspring has white flowers?

Choose one answer for question 9
Show solutionHide solution for question 9

Answer D · 968\frac9{68}

Key idea The observed offspring change how likely the selected parent is to be heterozygous.

  1. The original cross is Aa×AaAa\times Aa. Among its purple offspring, the proportions are

    P(AA)=13,P(Aa)=23.P(AA)=\frac13,\qquad P(Aa)=\frac23.
  2. If the selected parent is AAAA, both first offspring must be purple. If it is AaAa, the probability that both are purple is (3/4)2=9/16(3/4)^2=9/16.

    The two routes to the observed result therefore have weights

    AA: 13=824,Aa: 23916=924.AA:\ \frac13=\frac8{24},\qquad Aa:\ \frac23\frac9{16}=\frac9{24}.
  3. Restricting to those routes, the probability that the selected parent is AaAa is 9/(8+9)=9/179/(8+9)=9/17.

    Only an AaAa parent can produce a white offspring by self-pollination; its probability of doing so is 1/41/4. Hence

    917×14=968.\frac9{17}\times\frac14=\boxed{\frac9{68}}.

Common trap Saying each new fertilisation makes the earlier evidence irrelevant. Fertilisations are independent for a known genotype; here the genotype is uncertain.

Conceptual starting point: NSAA 2023, Section 1, Q68. ESAT scope: B4.2–B4.3; M7.7.

Question 10BiologyTranspiration & experimental data

From bubble movement to water loss

Two watertight bubble potometers, X and Y, measure water uptake by two leafy shoots. The capillaries have uniform circular cross-sections. Measurements are:

Potometer measurements
MeasurementXY
Internal capillary diameter0.80 mm0.80\text{ mm}1.20 mm1.20\text{ mm}
Distance moved by bubble24 mm24\text{ mm}32 mm32\text{ mm}
Time taken4.0 min4.0\text{ min}8.0 min8.0\text{ min}
Total leaf area60 cm260\text{ cm}^290 cm290\text{ cm}^2
Fraction of water uptake retained by shoot10%10\%20%20\%

During each measurement, the rest of the water taken up is lost by transpiration. There are no other water gains or losses.

What is the ratio of Y’s transpiration rate per unit leaf area to X’s?

Choose one answer for question 10
Show solutionHide solution for question 10

Answer A · 89\frac89

Key idea Convert distance to volume, divide by time and leaf area, then account for retained water.

  1. Water uptake is the volume swept by the bubble: πd2L/4\pi d^2L/4. Therefore the ratio of uptake rates per unit leaf area is

    YX=(1.200.80)23224486090.\frac{\text{Y}}{\text{X}}=\left(\frac{1.20}{0.80}\right)^2\frac{32}{24}\frac48\frac{60}{90}.
    =94×43×12×23=1.=\frac94\times\frac43\times\frac12\times\frac23=1.
  2. Only 80% of Y’s uptake and 90% of X’s uptake are transpired. The required ratio is therefore

    1×0.800.90=89.1\times\frac{0.80}{0.90}=\boxed{\frac89}.

A potometer measures water uptake. This question supplies the retained fractions so that actual water loss can be calculated.

Common trap Using capillary diameter instead of cross-sectional area, or treating water uptake as exactly equal to transpiration.

Conceptual starting point: NSAA 2023, Section 1, Q65. ESAT scope: B11.2c–e; M1.1; M3.5; M5.15.

Source ideas and syllabus coverage for each question

Q1 · Mathematics 1

ENGAA 2023, Section 1, Q5

Reverses a side-ratio/area problem: the area is fixed and both geometrically valid lengths must be recovered.

Specification: M4.16; M5.14.

Q2 · Mathematics 1

NSAA 2023, Section 1, Q20

Uses a two-counter transfer and asks for an earlier event conditional on a later observation.

Specification: M7.5–M7.7.

Q3 · Mathematics 2

ENGAA 2023, Section 1, Q25

Infers a negative ratio from a subsequence sum, then builds a third series from squared terms.

Specification: MM2.3.

Q4 · Mathematics 2

ENGAA 2023, Section 1, Q31 and Q33

Combines polynomial differentiation and integration with an unknown point of tangency and a second intersection.

Specification: MM1.6; MM6.2–MM6.3; MM7.1–MM7.2.

Q5 · Physics

ENGAA 2023, Section 1, Q4 and Q28

Combines switching with a power measurement in a different resistor; the branch voltage must be recalculated.

Specification: P1.2f, i–m.

Q6 · Physics

ENGAA 2023, Section 1, Q40

Adds a preceding inelastic collision and asks for one spring’s compression rather than the combined extension.

Specification: P3.3c–d; P3.6a–b; P3.7d, f.

Q7 · Chemistry

NSAA 2023, Section 1, Q51 and Q54

Combines gas-volume data and a back-titration to separate two reacting components from an inert impurity.

Specification: C4.3, C4.6, C4.8–C4.10; C9.1b, f.

Q8 · Chemistry

NSAA 2023, Section 1, Q60

Works backwards from mass and oxygen consumption to identify an unknown alcohol, with unequal carbon-product amounts.

Specification: C3.4; C4.1, C4.3, C4.6, C4.8; C13.1f; C13.5a.

Q9 · Biology

NSAA 2023, Section 1, Q68

Uses offspring observations to update the uncertain genotype of a parent selected by phenotype.

Specification: B4.2–B4.3; M7.7.

Q10 · Biology

NSAA 2023, Section 1, Q65

Compares different capillaries, times and leaf areas, then distinguishes uptake from transpiration using supplied retention data.

Specification: B11.2c–e; M1.1; M3.5; M5.15.

Make the difficult question useful

After each solution, write down the decision that unlocked it: subtract the surrounding areas, condition on the evidence, change the conservation law, or count atoms before substituting numbers. Then return to the question later and try to make that decision without help.

Keep regular practice mixed. These are deliberately demanding questions; your preparation should also include shorter questions that reward quick, accurate execution.

Sources and specification

This set was checked against UAT-UK’s content specification for the October 2026 and January 2027 sittings. Its archive identifies older questions outside ESAT’s scope; the new problems here use the topics listed in the source and syllabus notes above.

Original questions and solutions © 2026 Thriving Scholars. Source papers belong to Cambridge University Press & Assessment. Thriving Scholars is independent of UAT-UK and Cambridge University Press & Assessment.

Continue with ESAT preparation

Turn this guide into your next step.

Build a complete ESAT plan with module-specific practice, realistic mocks and expert guidance.Explore ESAT preparation